SynthMaker Production Manual Open SynthMaker (opens in a new tab)

What are stereo and mono, and why does the bass stay in the middle?

Stereo is two channels, left and right, and a sound's place between them is its pan; mono is one channel, as a phone or many club systems play it. The bass stays in the middle because a wide bass can cancel itself out when the two channels are added into one.

Two channels

A stereo song is two streams of sound, one for each speaker or ear. Where a sound seems to sit depends on how it's shared:

  • the same in both: it seems to come from the middle, even though no speaker is there;
  • louder on one side: it moves towards that side. Setting that balance is panning;
  • slightly different in each, in timing or tone: it sounds wide. Reverb and chorus do this.

Middle and sides

Any stereo sound can also be split into the middle, what's the same in both channels, and the sides, what's different. The middle usually carries the main parts (kick, bass, lead, voice), and the sides carry the width.

Mono: when the two become one

Mono is one channel. When stereo plays in mono, the two channels are added together, and the sides cancel out. A lot of listening is in mono: a phone's speaker, many smart and wireless speakers, and many club systems.

So check your mix in mono. Anything that lives only in the sides, such as the width of a reverb, fades there. That's fine for effects, but not for the bass.

Why the bass stays in the middle

1. A wide bass can cancel itself in mono. The quickest way to make a sound wide is to make one side a little late. But in mono the two copies are added, and where the delay is half a cycle, one copy goes up exactly as the other goes down. They cancel.

The lowest bass note in Lift, a song played by SynthMaker, is a D at 73.42 Hz (vibrations a second). Half a cycle of it takes 6.81 ms (thousandths of a second). Delay one side by that much and, in mono, the bass loses three quarters of its energy under 120 Hz.

2. The lows carry most of a mix's energy. In Lift, about 64% is under 250 Hz (page 4). Kept in the middle, they're played by both speakers equally, so they're solid wherever you stand.

3. You can barely hear where very low sounds come from. So spreading the deep bass gains little width, and risks the cancelling in reason 1.

The habit: keep the kick, the bass and the lowest part of everything else in the middle, and let the width live higher up. Lift's remaster did just that: it made the bass nearly mono. Below 120 Hz the sides are now more than 20 dB quieter than the middle.

Listen

1 and 2. The middle and the sides:

  • Middle: 16 seconds of Lift, only its middle, in both ears.0:00 / 0:16
  • Sides: the same bars, only its sides, turned up to the same loudness (in the song they're 7.8 dB quieter than the middle; a dB, or decibel, compares two levels, page 3). Listen for the space around the parts: mostly reverb, with less bass.0:00 / 0:16

3. A wide bass, then mono: Wide bass. Lift's bass alone, three times at one fixed level: in the middle, as in the song; made wide, with the right side 6.81 ms late; then that wide version in mono, as a phone plays it. Listen for the low end draining away the third time.

Wide bass0:00 / 0:12

Try it in SynthMaker

Make a wide sound, then hear what mono does to it. Use headphones.

  1. Make two Oscillators, both on wave Saw, and link the Voice's freq into each one's freq. Link the first one's out into the Output's in, and the second one's into the Output's right. With right linked, in becomes the left channel, so each saw has its own side.
  2. On the second Oscillator, set beat to 1/4. At 120 BPM (beats a minute) that makes it 2 Hz higher. Hold a note: the sound swirls between your ears.
  3. Turn on Listen as › Phone speaker (page 2 shows where it is), which plays in mono. The swirl becomes a throb, twice a second: the two saws line up and add, then cancel and dip.
  4. To place a sound instead of spreading it, link an LFO into the Output's pan (-1 is fully left, 1 fully right), and the sound will travel from side to side.

Where the numbers come from

  • Worked out: one cycle of 73.42 Hz is 1 ÷ 73.42 = 13.62 ms, so half is 6.81 ms; a 2 Hz difference throbs twice a second.
  • Measured from Lift and its bass stem (the bass as its own audio file): the sides against the middle, and the wide bass's loss in mono.
  • From the score: the bass's lowest note, a D at 73.42 Hz.
  • From SynthMaker's manual: the Output's right input and pan, the Oscillator's beat, and Listen as › Phone speaker playing in mono.