What is loudness, and what does LUFS mean?
Loudness is how loud a song sounds over its whole length, measured in LUFS, and louder isn't better: most players turn loud songs down to match the others, so squashing a song to make it louder only takes away its punch.
Peaks aren't loudness
Page 3 was about peaks: the highest points of the wave. But peaks don't tell you how loud something sounds. A short hit, such as a hi-hat, can peak right at the top and still sound quiet, because it's over in a moment. A held pad at the same peak sounds much louder, because it stays up there.
In Lift, a song played by SynthMaker, the pad set to the same peak as the hi-hats measures 10.1 dB louder (a dB, or decibel, compares two levels; page 3).
LUFS: loudness as you hear it
LUFS stands for Loudness Units relative to Full Scale. It comes from a standard loudness meter, built to agree with how loud people say things sound. It does three things:
- It weighs the sound roughly as your ears do: less of the very deep bass, a little more of the upper mids and highs.
- It measures the energy in short blocks, under half a second each.
- It averages them over the whole song, leaving out silence, so a quiet intro doesn't drag the number down.
The result is one number for the whole song. It's below zero, and closer to zero is louder: -14 LUFS is 2 dB louder than -16 LUFS.
A song's punch is the gap between its loudest peaks and its average loudness. A big gap means the drums still stand out. A small one means they've been flattened.
Lift, measured: -14.1 LUFS over the whole song, with 12.6 dB of punch.
Why louder isn't better
Page 2 showed the trap: louder sounds better when you compare. That led to a race to make every song louder. Once a song's peaks reach the ceiling, the only way to make it louder is to squash it. A limiter (a control that turns down only the loudest peaks) lowers the peaks, so the whole song can be turned up. The drum hits lose their snap, quiet and loud parts end up level, and the song tires your ears sooner.
Most streaming and video services turn songs to a set loudness before playing them. A song mastered louder is simply turned down, and keeps its flattened peaks. Many services aim at around -14 LUFS, which is why every piece SynthMaker publishes is mastered to -14 LUFS.
Listen
1 and 2. The same loudness, squashed and not:
Original: 16 seconds of Lift, finished.0:00 / 0:16 Squashed: the same, pushed 8 dB into a fast limiter. That made it only 3.8 dB louder: the rest was shaved off the peaks. It was then turned back down to match the first. Listen to the kick: every hit is shaved off at the top.0:00 / 0:16
At the same loudness, the squashed version's punch drops from 10.3 dB to 7.3 dB. That's what it lost.
3. Same peak, different loudness: Same peak. 6 seconds of Lift's hi-hats alone, then 6 seconds of its pad (the drone and chords together), both at exactly the same peak. Listen to how much louder the pad sounds.
Try it in SynthMaker
Make a sound louder without making its peaks higher, and hear what it costs.
- Open a plucked sound, one that starts with a hit and fades away. Add a Shaper after its VCA, just before the Output, with shape set to Soft. Put an Analyzer after it and show the Scope.
- Turn drive from 1 up to 8. The Soft curve never lets anything past full height, but it lifts the quiet parts: at drive 8 the quiet tail is about 8 times bigger, +18 dB. On the Scope the tail fills out: the same peak, more loudness, and less like a pluck.
- Turn the Shaper's mix between 0 and 1 to compare. The squashed one sounds louder, so turn the VCA's level down until they match. Then decide which you prefer.
Where the numbers come from
- Measured with a standard loudness meter (EBU R128): every loudness, punch and peak figure on this page.
- Worked out: the Soft Shaper's curve, from SynthMaker's engine, gives quiet sounds a gain of drive / tanh(drive): at drive 8, that's 8.0, or +18.1 dB.
- From the published standard behind EBU R128: the meter's ear-shaped filter, its 400 ms blocks, and how it leaves out silence.
- A published figure, not measured here: many streaming services play songs at about -14 LUFS. SynthMaker's own target of -14 LUFS is our house rule.
- The limiter in example 2 is SynthMaker's mastering limiter.