How should I listen while making music?
Check your music on more than one kind of speaker, because each one hides something different, and only ever compare two versions at the same loudness, because the louder one nearly always seems better.
Every speaker hides something
People will hear your song on whatever they have, so a good mix has to work on all of it.
Headphones show detail, like a reverb that's too long. But each ear hears only its own side, so left and right sound further apart than on speakers.
Speakers put the sound in a room, where both ears hear both. But a small room can make some bass notes much louder than others.
A phone is where most people will hear your music first. Its tiny speaker plays almost nothing under about 300 Hz (hertz: vibrations a second; low numbers are low notes, page 4). It also plays in mono: one channel instead of two (page 6). Through a phone-like filter, Lift, a song played by SynthMaker, keeps only 21% of its energy.
So how do you hear a bass on a phone at all? Through its overtones: higher copies of each note, at 2, 3, 4 and more times its pitch. Lift's lowest bass note is 73.42 Hz, but the copy at 5 times that, 367 Hz, is inside a phone's range. Your ear fills in the missing low note. That's why a bass with some grit survives on a phone, and a pure, deep one disappears.
Laptop speakers sit in between: a bit more bass than a phone.
So check on several. Mix mostly on one you know well, then check on the others.
Compare at the same loudness
This is the most important habit in the whole course. When two versions differ in loudness, the louder one usually sounds better: fuller, brighter, more exciting, even when nothing else differs. Your ears hear more of the lows and highs as the level goes up.
So if adding reverb also makes a sound louder, you can't tell whether you like the reverb or just the loudness. The fix: turn the louder version down until both are equally loud, then compare. Every before-and-after example in this course is matched like that, unless the page is about level itself.
Listen quieter than you think. Tired ears judge badly, so take breaks.
Listen
1. Full range, then a phone:
Full range: 16 seconds of Lift, finished.0:00 / 0:16 Phone: the same as a phone plays it, at the same loudness. Listen for the kick: it all but vanishes, because it's almost all under 250 Hz.0:00 / 0:16
2. The loudness trap:
Full range again, then0:00 / 0:16 Louder: exactly the same audio, 2 dB louder (dB, or decibels, compare two levels; page 3). If it sounded better, that's the trap.0:00 / 0:16
Try it in SynthMaker
SynthMaker can play everything as a phone or a laptop would, without changing the sound itself.
- Open Fuzz Bass and play some low notes.
- Turn on Listen as › Phone speaker: mono, 300 Hz to 6 kHz (6,000 Hz). It's in the View menu on the Mac; in the web app it's a menu of its own, next to the play button. While it's on, SynthMaker shows it: a badge, or in the web app, the menu turns yellow.
- The bass survives, because its Shaper adds grit in the range a phone plays. Set the Shaper's mix to 0 (no grit): the bass nearly disappears. Set it back to 1.
- Try Listen as › Laptop speakers (150 Hz to 12 kHz). To turn it off, choose Off on the Mac or As is in the web app, or click the badge.
Where the numbers come from
- Measured with a phone-like filter (one channel, everything under 300 Hz and over 6 kHz removed): the share of Lift's energy a phone keeps.
- Measured from Lift's stems (each part as its own audio file): how much of the kick lies under 250 Hz.
- Measured with a standard loudness meter (EBU R128): the 2 dB between the two files in example 2.
- Worked out: 5 × 73.42 Hz = 367 Hz.
- From SynthMaker's manual: the Listen as ranges. The phone example uses the same range; the app's own filters may differ in steepness.